Really like this pencil. It is soft and goes on easily. The color appeared a bit purple in picture, but it goes on more like shades of browns. I use it more as a brow pencil, Works well with another non-oil based pencil. Would try other colors. MoreReally like this pencil. It is soft and goes on easily. The color appeared a bit purple in picture, but it goes on more like shades of browns. I use it more as a brow pencil, Works well with another non-oil based pencil. Would try other colors. Less

Great product and love the colour MoreGreat product and love the colour Less

Does as described. Stays in place. Great product MoreDoes as described. Stays in place. Great product Less

My current daily go to as well as the copper by the same brand. Soft and gentle of the eyes which disperses by the end of the day and gives a smudged look - which is fine by me, but this pencil is on the gentle side - might pile it on for night time smudged look. Lovely pencil that will be a repeat purchase for me MoreMy current daily go to as well as the copper by the same brand. Soft and gentle of the eyes which disperses by the end of the day and gives a smudged look - which is fine by me, but this pencil is on the gentle side - might pile it on for night time smudged look. Lovely pencil that will be a repeat purchase for me Less

I’ve been trying to clean up my make up routine and I was pleasantly surprised by this eyeliner. It goes in so smooth and stays in place. I love the color! Highly recommend

Excellent shade. Smooth application.

Love this eye pencil, it goes on smooth and stays on me all day. Knowing that it’s a less toxic makeup makes it so much more enjoyable to wear!

Lovely smooth application and no smudge.

I like the color but it was hard to apply and i felt like not much came onto my eye.

Really like this pencil. It is soft and goes on easily. The color appeared a bit purple in picture, but it goes on more like shades of browns. I use it more as a brow pencil, Works well with another non-oil based pencil. Would try other colors.

Great product and love the colour

Does as described. Stays in place. Great product

I have purchased different colors in the past and I am so excited to try the Copper for fall, it looks beautiful:)

I never would have picked this but I love it. The unique color is flattering and goes well with the recommended eye shadow.

Really like this pencil. It is soft and goes on easily. The color appeared a bit purple in picture, but it goes on more like shades of browns. I use it more as a brow pencil, Works well with another non-oil based pencil. Would try other colors. MoreReally like this pencil. It is soft and goes on easily. The color appeared a bit purple in picture, but it goes on more like shades of browns. I use it more as a brow pencil, Works well with another non-oil based pencil. Would try other colors. Less

Great product and love the colour MoreGreat product and love the colour Less

It glides on and stays put. Very pretty color!

Just a subtle pop of color. Love it!! Goes on smoothly.

Really like this pencil. It is soft and goes on easily. The color appeared a bit purple in picture, but it goes on more like shades of browns. I use it more as a brow pencil, Works well with another non-oil based pencil. Would try other colors.

Great product and love the colour

I love the ease of applying this eyeliner. The color highlights my hazel eyes.

Lovely smooth application and no smudge.

It's exactly what I was looking for -- the color is great and it glides on beautifully!

Works fine

This is the second color of this eye pencil, this time I purchased Opal and I have the Earth color as well. They both go well with my blue eyes and brown (with some grey) hair. They glide on smoothly and don't irritate the thin skin of my eyelid.

Really like this pencil. It is soft and goes on easily. The color appeared a bit purple in picture, but it goes on more like shades of browns. I use it more as a brow pencil, Works well with another non-oil based pencil. Would try other colors.

Great product and love the colour

Does as described. Stays in place. Great product

I love this pencil. The color is great. It goes on easily and it's easy to adjust the look and intensity of it. I'm pleased with how long the pencil is lasting and how nice it sharpens. Definitely would recommend!

I used to buy purple eyeliner from another brand (definitely not a cruelty-free, nontoxic brand) and really missed it - purple definitely makes hazel eyes pop! While Agate is definitely much more subtle, it's more versatile and pretty because of that.

Better yet, I've used it several times and still have not had an allergic reaction to it. Usually I just need one or two uses of a product to know if I'm going to react, so I feel pretty confident in saying this eyeliner is great for sensitive skin.

I'll definitely be buying this again!

Really like this pencil. It is soft and goes on easily. The color appeared a bit purple in picture, but it goes on more like shades of browns. I use it more as a brow pencil, Works well with another non-oil based pencil. Would try other colors.

Great product and love the colour

This goes on very well and is long lasting. Depending on my skin on the day (if it is more oily) there is some transfer to my upper lids but then I guess I just get a smokey eye. If you want very precise, this is probably not the choice for you but it works good for a simple swipe for everyday.

this is so easy for a quick make up routine. one of my new fave.

Eyeliner good color goes on smooth, BUT it doesn’t stay on, have to reapply several times and wipe under eye

Really like this pencil. It is soft and goes on easily. The color appeared a bit purple in picture, but it goes on more like shades of browns. I use it more as a brow pencil, Works well with another non-oil based pencil. Would try other colors.